The "Locals" Food Tour

2 days • Always Available

Discover the heart of Wisconsin's food scene in theSugar River Valley, where smokehouses serve up mouthwatering local meats and small-town breweries pour perfect pints. And do so like a local...

You'll find legendary Friday fish fries that bring the community together for golden-brown fillets and all the fixings, family-run ice cream shops that dish up creamy, hand-churned scoops that'll make everyone smile, and much more. Happy eating!

Kennedy's Ice Cream & Grill
Chalet Landhaus Restaurant & Inn
Kristi's Restaurant
Tofflers Pub & Grill
Grumpy Troll Brew Pub
The Dog House Bar & Grill
Sunn Cafe
AzTec Taqueria
5th Quarter Bar & Grill
Grace Coffee Co
North and South Seafood & Smokehouse
Riley Tavern
Kennedy's Ice Cream & Grill

1. Kennedy's Ice Cream & Grill

A hot spot to cool off in May - October, Kennedy's Ice Cream & Grill is a must-stop in New Glarus. They're known for their sweet and savory foods – from ice cream and burgers to mouth-watering steak sandwiches.

The hometown spot is particularly loved for its open-air, walk-up counter, and reasonably-priced food that tastes great. Plus, they have amazing sundaes kids and adults can't get enough of.

Chalet Landhaus Restaurant & Inn

2. Chalet Landhaus Restaurant & Inn

Not only does Chalet Landhaus Restaurant & Inn have amazing and authentic Swiss cuisine, but they also offer opportunities to experience live traditional Swiss music in the summer months. They're open for breakfast and dinner, and you can belly up to The Älpli Bar – a cozy, full-service bar adjoining the Chalet Landhaus Restaurant & Inn.

Don't miss out on the Swiss Cookout every Thursday – buffet style with lots (we mean lots) of Swiss options!

Kristi's Restaurant

3. Kristi's Restaurant

Beloved by locals as "the perfect date night spot" this hometown restaurant offers a fantastic birds-eye view of downtown New Glarus from the wrap-around front porch.

Kristi's Restaurant have a warm and welcoming atmosphere in a building that was one of the first homes downtown. An impressive menu for the area considering you're in the heart of the Midwest, Kristi's boasts traditional foods with a Mexican influence.

Tofflers Pub & Grill

4. Tofflers Pub & Grill

No frills, all the fun – Tofflers Pub & Grill is a staple for sipping pints of local beer, listening to live music, and spending time with the family.

The pub's vibrant atmosphere is great for all ages – and dogs too! Bring the kids and pups, and let them run around the big patio. It's also the best spot to hear live music throughout the summer.

Grumpy Troll Brew Pub

5. Grumpy Troll Brew Pub

Nestled in the heart of Mount Horeb (like a troll under a bridge), don't miss out on Grumpy Troll Brew Pub. An award-winning brewery, its ales and lagers brewed on-site bring locals and travelers from afar to town.

They also serve up scratch-made food you can enjoy, including a variety of pub favorites like pizzas, burgers, sandwiches, and regional specialties.

The Dog House Bar & Grill

6. The Dog House Bar & Grill

One of 8 places in the state that won the Wisconsin Beef Council’s “Best Burgers in Wisconsin” competition, The Dog House Bar & Grill knows how to serve up good eats.

Hand-pattied, always fresh, never frozen burger grilled to perfection and nestled between layers of melted, anyone?! Oh, and they have fried cheese curds too, of course!

Sunn Cafe

7. Sunn Cafe

Looking for a coffee shop meets lunch spot that serves up handmade sandwiches and healthy eats with a cute vibe? Look no further than Sunn Cafe in the heart of downtown Mount Horeb.

Their cozy atmosphere is packed with locals but its welcoming vibe is great for visitors too. Make sure to try their mix of soups, and sandwiches, and you can even snag a can of local beer from their help-yourself cooler.

AzTec Taqueria

8. AzTec Taqueria

Find authentic Mexican food in the middle of Verona at AzTec Taqueria. Their menu is strongly influenced by taco trucks and Swap Meet Food with an indigenous twist.

Inspired by countless generations of Mexican cooking traditions from growing up in Fresno, CA, this locally owned and operated restaurant has the best tacos, tortillas, and burritos around.

5th Quarter Bar & Grill

9. 5th Quarter Bar & Grill

You can't go to Wisconsin without an authentic fish fry. Head to 5th Quarter Bar & Grill for fried perch, cod, or shrimp. All dinners include homemade coleslaw, French bread, and a choice of potato, of course.

You can catch sports games here too and grab a pint from the bar featuring local breweries and Wisconsin staples like New Glarus Brewing Company beers.

Grace Coffee Co

10. Grace Coffee Co

A huge coffee shop with a cozy and comfortable atmosphere, Grace Coffee Co is loved by visitors and locals alike.

Their bright seating area is great for groups of friends or to grab a spot to get some work done. Plus, they have a big patio to enjoy in the summer. Sip on specialty coffees, order breakfast, and enjoy lunch options – or a simple but tasty pastry if you prefer.

North and South Seafood & Smokehouse

11. North and South Seafood & Smokehouse

If you're into Old Fashioneds or smoked meats, this is your spot. Our local insider told us North and South Seafood & Smokehouse is the best place to get one in all of Verona.

The lowkey and laid-back restaurant is a local favorite for hearty portions and hand-shaken drinks from the bar. Their massive menu has a tasty variety of seafood and BBQ entrees, as well as combinations and sides galore.

Riley Tavern

12. Riley Tavern

Step into the air-conditioned tavern or grab a picnic table on the Riley Yard for their famous Sunday pancake breakfast. 2020 silver winner of Best of Madison categories for Best Bloody Mary and Best Outdoor Dining. Breakfast is served on Sundays only from 9 to noon, so get here early!

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12